FRCA Notes


Post-Dural Puncture Headache

An SAQ on the topic from 2017 gave marks for differential diagnosis, features of a sinister underlying cause and risks of epidural blood patches.

A CRQ in 2023 (77% pass rate) was 'well answered', but marks were lost on performance of an epidural blood patch.

Resources


  • A PDPH is a debilitating postural headache following therapeutic or diagnostic interventions of the epidural or spinal (intrathecal) space
  • In all cases of suspected PDPH, other causes of headache must be excluded

Patient factors

  • Young age
  • Female gender
  • Low BMI
  • Dehydration
  • Pregnant
  • Previous PDPH

Procedural factors

  • Diagnostic lumbar puncture: incidence 30-50%

  • Epidural anaesthesia
    • The incidence of dural puncture is 0 - 2.6% (1 in 50)
    • The risk of developing PDPH after accidental dural puncture occurs is 70 - 80%
    • The risk is inversely proportional to the experience of the anaesthetist i.e. more common with junior anaesthetist
    • Loss of resistance to air may increase risk, as use of air can cause pneumocephalus

  • Spinal anaesthesia
    • Incidence of PDPH 0 - 5% (1 in 500)
    • Incidence increased by:
      • Cutting needle e.g. Quincke
      • Larger needle i.e. <25G
      • Multiple attempts e.g. 'pepper-potting' the dura
      • Large volume CSF escape
      • No use of intrathecal catheter
    • Reduced incidence with pencil-point needle e.g. Sprotte, Whitacre or smaller needle >25G

  • Dural puncture is intentional in spinal anaesthesia and lumbar puncture, and a recognised complication of epidural placement
  • CSF leaks from the dural tear, causing a fall in ICP and sagging of the brain in the skull vault
  • This causes downwards traction on pain-sensitive structures e.g. meninges, intra-cranial nerves, blood vessels
  • Fall in ICP may cause compensatory venodilation, contributing to headache

Headache

  • 90% develop a severe headache within 72hrs of dural puncture

  • Fronto-occipital headache that may radiate into the neck and shoulders
    • Frontal headache via ophthalmic branch of trigeminal nerve
    • Occipital headache via glossopharyngeal and vagus nerves
  • Typically worse sitting or standing, better lying down
  • Pressure over the abdomen with the woman in the upright position may give transient relief to the headache by raising intracranial pressure secondary to a rise in intrabdominal pressure (Gutsche sign)

Associated features

Symptom Notes
Meningism Vomiting, neck stiffness and photophobia
Due to C1-3 nerve root irritation
Diplopia and visual symptoms Effect on CN III, IV and VI
of which abducens (VI) most sensitive to lower CSF volume
Vertigo, tinnitus and hearing loss From interaction between perilymph and CSF
Scalp paraesthesia
Limb paraesthesia
Cranial nerve palsy

Investigations

  • Neuro-imaging is indicated when:
    • The headache is atypical
    • The headache changes in nature
    • There are associated neurological signs
    • There is reduced GCS
    • >2 EBP's have been unsuccessful

  • Vascular
    • PET
    • Migraine
    • Central venous sinus thrombosis
    • Subdural or subarachnoid haemorrhage
    • PRES
  • Infectious e.g. meningitis (septic or aseptic)
  • Neoplastic e.g. space-occupying lesion
  • Metabolic
    • Caffeine withdrawal
    • Dehydration
  • Other
    • Tension headache
    • Lactation headache
    • Idiopathic intracranial hypertension
    • Pneumocephalus

  • Accidental dural puncture during epidural insertion is evidenced by:
    • Brisk CSF leak from the Tuohy needle
    • Said fluid is warm (saline used in LOR will be room temperature)
    • If unsure one could dipstick the fluid:
Factor CSF Saline
pH 7.5 - 8.5 5.5
Protein + or ++ None
Glucose Trace or + None
  • If a dural tap occurs one is left with two options:
    1. Remove needle and re-site at a different interspace
      • One should beware intrathecal spread of infused LA
      • Anaesthetist-only top-ups
      • If headache develops during labour then consider assisted delivery as excessive straining may cause increased CSF leak

    2. Thread the epidural catheter into the intrathecal space

Intrathecal catheter

  • Advantages of threading the epidural catheter into the intrathecal space include:
    • Provides excellent analgesia
    • Reduces risk of further dural puncture
    • Reduces risk of PDPH, putatively by fibroblast proliferation around the catheter entry site

  • Disadvantages include:
    • Labour intensive for anaesthetist as must deliver all top up doses onself
    • Risk of high spinal
    • Risk of infection

  • If this method is used, then:
    • Leave at most 3cm in the intrathecal space to reduce risk of neurological damage
    • Clearly label as a spinal catheter
    • Anaesthetist-only top-ups
    • Cautious (1 - 2ml bag mix) top ups every 2 - 4hrs
    • Inform senior anaesthetist, midwife and woman of the events
    • Document in notes, incident form etc.

  • Arrange daily follow up for the patient by a (senior) anaesthetist
  • Provide written information e.g. local or OAA leaflet
  • Offer follow-up after discharge to ensure no ongoing complications

  • Most PDPH's resolve spontaneously by 10 days, but up to 10% still present at 1 month

Conservative treatment

  • Bed rest
  • Avoid raising ICP e.g. regular laxatives, avoid straining/lifting
  • Avoid dehydration (although the historical recommendation of IV fluid administration is not thought to be of benefit)

  • Caffeine provides temporary benefit vs. placebo (weak evidence, Cochrane review 2015)
    • Dose max 900mg/24hrs PO (or 200mg/24hrs PO if breastfeeding)
    • Not recommended beyond 24hrs by the OAA
    • Thought to act by inducing cerebral vasoconstriction

Analgesia

  • Regular simple analgesia
  • Opioid analgesia (avoid codeine in breastfeeding) often not very effective
  • Debatable efficacy of gabapentin, which may reduce pain score but not need for blood patch
  • Historical treatments e.g. sumatriptan, abdominal binders have not been shown to be effective

Other interventional treatment

  • Greater occipital nerve block: weak evidence and not recommended by consensus statement
  • Sphenopalatine ganglion block: blocking the ganglion impairs parasympathetic-induced cerebral vasodilation, but may actually work via placebo effect
  • Epidural fluids; may provide short - term benefit but do not provide long - term relief

  • Perform >24hrs after initial injury and >48hrs after onset of symptoms
    • Less effective if performed within 48hrs

Contraindications

  • Maternal anticoagulation
  • Systemic infection/sepsis
  • Localised infection over insertion site
  • Neurological pathology suspected, although presence of malignancy not necessarily a contraindication (BJA, 2021)
  • Patient refusal

Performance

  • Most senior anaesthetist should perform the blood patch
  • Perform the patch at the same level or one space below initial puncture site
  • Aim to inject 10 - 20ml slowly (may cause pain due to arachnoid irritation)
  • Patient lying flat for at least 2hrs post patch

Efficacy

  • The first patch provides: (BJA, 2022)
    • Complete relief in ∽33%
    • Partial relief in ∽39%
    • Failure in ∽28%
      • Only three-quarters of these receive a second patch
  • Overall partial or complete relief occurs in 50-80%
  • The RCoA say 60-70% will experience cure within 24hrs of an EBP
  • Labourpains say 1 in 5 will fail

Failure

  • There are statistically significant associations between EBP failure and:
    • Patient history of migraine
    • Higher dural puncture (L1 - 3) vs. lower (L3 - 5)
    • EBP performed <48hrs after dural puncture
  • NB EBP volume not associated with risk of failure

Complications of EBP

  • (Another) dural puncture
  • Back pain:
    • 50% during the procedure
    • 80% at 24hrs post-EBP
    • May continue for several days, but mostly resolved within 4 weeks and not associated with chronic back pain
  • Neurological complications inc. meningitis, SDH, arachnoiditis, seizures

  • Chronic headache at 6 months, with a RR of approximately 2 vs. those who didn't experience a PDPH (BJA, 2022)
  • Subdural haemorrhage
  • Seizures
  • Central venous sinus thrombosis
  • Cranial nerve palsy
  • Persistent CSF leak causing intracranial hypotension ± chronic headache
  • Brainstem compression & death