FRCA Notes


Airways in Critical Care


  • Around 25% of major airway complications reported to NAP4 occurred in ICU or the emergency department
  • 45% of critically ill patients experience at least one major adverse event during intubation (INTUBE study, 2021):
    • Cardiovascular instability: up to 43%
    • Severe hypoxaemia (SpO2 <80%): 9%
    • Cardiac arrest: 3%
  • A major adverse event is associated with ↑ ICU and 28-day mortality
  • Failure of first-pass success significantly increases the risk of these events

  • In elective practice the main challenge is usually the anatomically difficult airway
  • In critical care the deranged physiology and poor reserve of the patient is often the greater threat - the physiologically difficult airway
  • Anatomical difficulty still occurs, and is compounded by environmental and human factors
Factor Notes
Respiratory ↓ FRC & shunt reduce effectiveness of preoxygenation
↓ safe apnoea time
Cardiovascular Absolute (e.g. haemorrhage) or relative (e.g. sepsis) hypovolaemia
LV systolic/diastolic dysfunction
RV dysfunction (e.g. ARDS with ↑ PVR)
Poor tolerance of induction agents and positive pressure ventilation
Metabolic ↑ VO2 from sepsis, fever, agitation and pain
Pre-existing acidosis worsened by apnoea
Anatomical Assessment often limited by time or patient cooperation
C-spine immobilisation, airway trauma or oedema
No option to wake the patient if intubation fails
Aspiration risk Uncertain starvation status
Gastric stasis from critical illness
Gastric distension from NIV or HFNO
Neurological Agitation or confusion may impair preoxygenation
Environmental Cramped bed space, monitoring and organ support devices
Unfamiliar or unavailable equipment (e.g. VL, bougies)
Human factors Ad-hoc teams; variable operator expertise
Cognitive overload and emotional burden of an emergency


  • Assessment is often time-critical and brief, so should focus on the most important features e.g. interincisor distance and the upper lip bite test
  • The MACOCHA score is the only assessment tool designed and validated in critically ill patients:
Factor Description Score
Mallampati score III or IV 5
Obstructive sleep Apnoea Present 2
Cervical spine Reduced mobility 1
Mouth Opening <3cm 1
Coma Present 1
Hypoxaemia SpO2 <80% 1
Non-Anaesthetist As airway operator 1
  • A score ≥3 predicts difficult intubation
  • Unique in including conscious level (protective reflexes and respiratory drive) and operator training
  • High specificity (89%) and NPV (98%), but low PPV (36%)

  • Other assessment may be warranted e.g.:
    • Nasendoscopy in suspected laryngeal pathology
    • Laryngeal handshake or ultrasound to identify the cricothyroid membrane
    • Gastric ultrasound to assess gastric contents

Mechanisms of cardiovascular collapse

  • Cardiovascular instability is the most common adverse event of intubation in critical care
  • It results from the interplay of several factors:
    • Hypovolaemia: absolute (haemorrhage, burns) or relative (sepsis, anaphylaxis)
    • Cardiac dysfunction: LV systolic or diastolic dysfunction; RV dysfunction e.g. in ARDS
    • Induction drugs: vasodilation and negative inotropy (especially propofol), and abolition of a compensatory sympathetic drive
    • Neuromuscular blockade and positive pressure ventilation: loss of negative pressure breathing and ↓ venous return
  • These effects are more pronounced in older and frailer patients

Optimisation

  • Perform a focused haemodynamic assessment before every emergency intubation
  • Optimise volume status and/or start vasopressors pre-emptively
  • The PrePARE trials found a routine 500ml crystalloid bolus in unselected patients did not prevent cardiovascular collapse
  • Treating genuine hypovolaemia on an individual basis remains important
  • The role of routine pre-emptive vasopressors is the subject of ongoing trials

Physiology

  • Severe hypoxaemia is the second most common adverse event (around 9%)
  • Safe apnoea time is described as the time for SpO2 to fall from 100% to 90%, beyond which rapid desaturation occurs
  • The FRC is the main oxygen store
    • Is about 30-35ml/kg in a healthy adult sitting upright
    • Reduced in the critical care cohort due to age, poor positioning, pulmonary disease including ARDS

  • VO2 in a paralysed healthy adult is around 250ml/min, but is increased in the critical care patient by sepsis, fever, agitation and pain
  • ↓ FRC and ↑ VO2 both shorten the safe apnoea time and reduce the effectiveness of conventional preoxygenation

Preoxygenation

  • Provide an FiO2 of 1.0 with a good mask seal and target end-tidal oxygen >85%
  • Patients with moderate-to-severe hypoxaemia should receive positive pressure preoxygenation, which recruits lung and ↑ FRC
    • NIV reduces hypoxaemia compared with standard facemask preoxygenation (PREOXI, 2024)
    • NIV may be superior to HFNO in moderate-to-severe hypoxaemia, although this comes from subgroup data only
    • Combined NIV and HFNO may be better than NIV alone, but beware ↑ airway pressures

Apnoeic oxygenation

  • During apnoea, oxygen is absorbed from the alveoli faster than CO2 is added (around 210ml/min net)
  • This creates a pressure gradient which draws oxygen from the pharynx into the alveoli by mass flow
  • Requires a patent airway
  • Associated with less desaturation during intubation in critically ill patients

Mask ventilation after induction

  • Gentle facemask ventilation (15-17cmH2O) between induction and laryngoscopy ↑ saturations and halves severe hypoxaemia (PreVent, 2019)
  • Studied in patients at low risk of aspiration, with no increase in aspiration seen


Agent Notes
Propofol Used in around 40% of ICU intubations worldwide
Vasodilation and negative inotropy
Independently associated with cardiovascular collapse and cardiac arrest
Ketamine Favourable haemodynamic profile; recommended by guidelines
Some evidence of lower mortality compared with etomidate
Etomidate Favourable haemodynamic profile; recommended by guidelines
Adrenal suppression via 11β-hydroxylase inhibition, even after a single dose in sepsis
  • There is no definitive evidence favouring ketamine over etomidate; both are reasonable choices

Other aspects of technique

  • Cricoid pressure has no proven benefit in preventing aspiration and may worsen the laryngeal view
  • Point-of-care ultrasound can identify the cricothyroid membrane and assess gastric contents
  • Awake tracheal intubation is not just a theatre technique and may be suitable in selected ICU patients

Videolaryngoscopy

  • VL is now recommended as the defaulty tool for all critically ill patients requiring intubation
Advantages Disadvantages
↑ first-pass success
Better glottic view, including with MILS
↓ oesophageal intubation
Shared view turns intubation into a team task
Useful rescue device after failed DL
Good teaching tool
Blood or secretions may obscure the view
Screen visibility in bright light
Good view does not always mean easy tube passage
Risk of prolonged attempts and desaturation
Learning curve (around 75 intubations for 90% first-pass success)

Evidence

  • Early RCTs and a systematic review found no improvement in first-pass success, and possibly more complications
    • Likely due to inexperienced operators, low use of adjuncts and prolonged attempts despite a good view

  • More recent evidence supports VL:
    • A Cochrane review (all settings) found VL of any design reduces failed intubation and hypoxaemia
    • The INTUBE subanalysis found ↑ first-pass success with VL (84% vs 79%), despite VL being used in patients with more predictors of difficulty
      • No increase in major adverse events once adjusted for operator experience
      • Fewer oesophageal intubations
      • VL rescued around 9% of failed DL attempts
    • The DEVICE trial (NEJM, 2023) found much higher first-pass success with VL (85% vs 71%), with no difference in severe complications
  • The debate has largely moved from whether VL is better than DL, to how to implement VL more widely

Blades and adjuncts

  • Most studies used Macintosh-type blades
  • Hyperangulated blades improve laryngeal exposure, but shift the difficulty from seeing the glottis to delivering the tube
    • A shaped stylet or bougie is essential, and requires specific training
    • Consider for predicted difficult airways (e.g. MACOCHA ≥3) or as a rescue device

Other devices

  • Fibreoptic scopes remain essential and VL is not a substitute, e.g. for airway inspection, bronchial toilet, sampling, percutaneous tracheostomy and checking tube position
  • SADs remain important rescue devices after failed intubation
    • Limited protection from aspiration
    • Laryngeal oedema after prolonged intubation may make SAD rescue less effective

Confirmation with capnography

  • Oesophageal intubation occurs in almost 6% of ICU intubations; if unrecognised it leads to hypoxaemia, cardiac arrest and death
  • Waveform capnography is the gold standard for confirming tracheal tube placement
    • Lack or misinterpretation of capnography contributed to 74% of ICU deaths or brain injuries in NAP4
    • INTUBE found capnography was used in only 25% of ICU intubations
  • Auscultation and other clinical signs are unreliable, especially in the critically ill
  • Use capnography whenever an airway procedure or sedation is performed

Recruitment

  • Post-intubation recruitment manoeuvres (Pinsp 30-40cmH2O for up to 30s) may improve hypoxaemia without adverse incidents

  • ICU and ED are cognitively complex environments: noise, cramped spaces, unfamiliar teams and the emotional burden of an emergency
  • Strategies include:
    • Use of a checklist and briefing before intubation
    • Cognitive aids such as simple visual algorithms
    • Shifting from an individual to a team approach, aided by the shared view of VL
    • Clear communication
    • Simulation training, debriefing and audit of airway practice
    • Designing bed spaces with emergency airway access in mind