FRCA Notes


Prehabilitation

The curriculum asks us to 'Describe strategies for prehabilitation and patient optimisation and the limits of such strategies'.

Prehabilitation was the subject of an SAQ in March 2019 (71% pass rate) with poor answers on 'basic sciences...[and] the benefits of carbohydrate preloading'.

Resources


  • The overall risk of death and major complications from surgery is low (<2%)
  • However, poorer outcomes are seen in patients with impaired pre-operative functional capacity
    • Typically includes the elderly, the frail or the multiply co-morbid patient
    • These higher-risk patients represent 12.5% of the surgical population, but account for 80% of post-operative deaths

  • Although there is no consistent or widely-accepted definition of prehabilitation (BJA, 2024), it can be thought of as:

The practice of enhancing a patient's pre-operative functional capacity, with the aim of improving post-operative outcomes

  • Major surgery causes a host of physiological responses, including:
    • A catabolic state
    • Systemic pro-inflammatory response including metabolic dysregulation
    • Muscle inflammation and mitochondrial dysfunction

  • The interventions which form prehabilitation aim to place the patient in a better state to withstand this insult and any post-operative complications which arise

Potential mechanisms

  • The physiological mechanisms are not fully understood; animal and preliminary human studies suggest prehabilitation may:
    • Have an anti-inflammatory effect: ↓ pro-inflammatory cytokines (IL-6, IL-1β, TNF) and ↑ anti-inflammatory cytokines (IL-10)
    • Reduce oxidative stress
    • Improve the immune response to infection
  • In cancer, these effects may also improve anti-tumour immune responses, and exercise may directly influence tumorigenicity via altered molecular pathways

Benefits of prehabilitation


Associated effects of prehabilitation programmes
↓ length of hospital stay
↓ length of critical care stay
↓ complication rate
↓ frailty scores
↑ QoL
↓ 1yr mortality
↑ disability-free survival

Constituent elements of prehabilitation

  • Programmes target their intervention during the 'teachable moment' period between deciding to proceed with surgery, and surgery itself
  • Most programmes are 4 - 8 weeks in duration, balancing effectiveness (reduced in shorter programmes) and compliance (reduced in longer programmes)

  • Prehabilitation programmes utilise an MDT to improve functionality via:
    1. Medical optimisation
    2. Physical exercise
    3. Nutritional support
    4. Psychological support
  • Programmes are most effective when delivered as a multimodal approach, combining several of these elements

Prehabilitation in cancer

  • The cancer continuum describes the stages of a patient's cancer experience:
    1. Before treatment (usually before surgery): the prehabilitation window
    2. Active treatment: chemotherapy, radiotherapy, hormonal therapy or immunotherapy
    3. Survival after the end of treatment
    4. For some, the palliative phase

  • Without intervention, both aerobic capacity and muscle strength decline throughout the cancer continuum
  • Goals of cancer prehabilitation:
    • Obtain baseline measurements of function before treatment commences
    • Improve a current health problem in preparation for surgery
    • Improve overall functioning to better withstand upcoming treatments
  • A programme started before surgery can often be continued, with minor modifications, throughout subsequent chemotherapy or radiotherapy
  • Exercise prehabilitation has, in some cases, moved patients from 'inoperable' to 'ready for surgery'

  • The time between diagnosis and treatment is often short as systems aim to begin cancer treatment within 2 - 4 weeks of diagnosis
  • Concerns about delaying treatment to allow prehabilitation may be overstated, with some evidence demonstrating lack of association between treatment delay and reduced overall survival
  • Focused programmes are feasible and safe even within this short timeframe
  • Anaesthetists are well placed to introduce or lead prehabilitation, as they often meet patients early via the pre-assessment clinic

Smoking cessation

  • Smoking is associated with a variety of adverse perioperative outcomes
  • Cessation may lead to:
    • ↓ Cardiovascular complications
    • ↓ Wound infections
    • Better wound healing and bone fusion
    • ↓ Length of stay
    • ↓ Mortality

Weight loss

  • The greatest risk of major post-operative complications occurs in the underweight patient
  • Obese patients tend to have higher rates of wound infections, blood loss and longer durations of surgery than normal weight patients
  • The obesity paradox, however, is that obese patients have better 30-day and long-term survival

Alcohol misuse

  • There is a dose-dependent increase in post-operative morbidity with alcohol consumption
  • Complications associated with excess alcohol consumption include immunosuppression, exaggerated stress response, cardiac insufficiency and haemostatic imbalance
  • 4 weeks of pre-operative abstinence can reduce perioperative morbidity

Other elements


  • Patients are screened for functional ability e.g. with the DASI
  • In those deemed at risk (e.g. DASI <34), baseline measurement of functional capacity should take place
    • Maximal testing e.g. CPET
    • Submaximal testing e.g. steep ramp test or 6-minute walk test
  • Repeat testing at the end of the programme may occur, to quantify changes in functional capacity

Exercise regimens

  • Appreciable muscle growth often cannot be achieved in the short timeframes available, but improved aerobic capacity and metabolic flexibility are possible
  • The optimal exercise regimen has not been defined, with existing programmes consisting of various:
    • Types of exercises, typically a blend of aerobic exercise and resistance training, although some include other aspects such as inspiratory muscle training, stretching or HIIT
    • Durations, from 2 weeks to 12 weeks
    • Frequency of sessions, from 1 to 5 sessions per week
    • Location, either more intense professionally supervised in-hospital sessions or home-based exercises

  • Exercise dose is described using the FITT principles:
    • Frequency: sessions per week
    • Intensity: percentage of maximum capacity
    • Time: duration in minutes
    • Type: modality of exercise
  • Cancer-specific exercise guidelines recommend:
    • ≥3 sessions per week of 30 minutes of moderate-intensity aerobic exercise
    • ≥2 sessions per week of resistance training: 2 sets of 8 - 15 repetitions at ≥60% of one-repetition maximum

Exercise intensity

  • Aerobic intensity can be prescribed by percentage of maximal heart rate, metabolic equivalents (METs) or the Borg scale
    • Maximal heart rate can be measured with CPET or estimated as 220 minus age
    • 1 MET is the energy used sitting at rest: 1 kcal/kg/h, or an oxygen uptake of 3.5 ml/kg/min
    • The Borg scale is a subjective rating of perceived exertion, running from 6 (no exertion at all) to 20 (maximal exertion)
  • Exercise intensity in prehabilitation programmes targets a Borg intensity of 12 - 16

Intensity % maximal heart rate METs Borg scale
Low - <3 8 - 11
Moderate
(can talk but not sing)
50 - 70% 3 - 6 12 - 15
High
(only a few words before needing a breath)
70 - 85% ≥6 16 - 18

  • HIIT alternates short bouts of high-intensity exercise with even shorter rest intervals
    • A quicker and more effective way to improve cardiovascular function and reduce fatigue than moderate-intensity endurance training
    • Suitable for most people, with positive effects shown in cancer prehabilitation

Supervised vs. home-based exercise

  • Supervised programmes are more effective at improving physical function and reducing fatigue
    • Likely due to better compliance, individualised support and peer support in group sessions
    • However, travel distance and cost are frequent barriers
  • Home-based programmes also improve physical function and may be a useful addition or alternative; digital and mobile technologies can assist delivery

Cancer-specific exercise interventions

  • Lung and oesophagogastric cancer: respiratory muscle training
    • Inspiratory and expiratory muscles trained with simple spirometry devices
    • Reduces breathing effort and respiratory muscle fatigue after as little as 1 week of daily exercise
    • Halved the risk of post-operative pulmonary complications in one lung cancer study
  • Prostate cancer: pre-operative pelvic floor muscle exercise is associated with reduced urinary incontinence 3 months after radical prostatectomy, but not at 6 months
  • Breast cancer: pre-operative range of motion exercises and information on lymphoedema risk factors may help preserve post-operative function after axillary node clearance

Outcomes

  • In cancer, exercise prehabilitation is safe and feasible, and is associated with improved physical function, QoL and fatigue, and with fewer post-operative complications, shorter length of stay and lower healthcare costs
  • There is some evidence for exercise-related tumour regression
  • The improvement in performance required to result in an improvement in surgical outcome is not known
  • The impact on long-term outcomes is unknown

  • Adverse nutritional status is associated with poor post-operative outcomes, such as:
    • Infectious complications
    • Length of stay
    • Readmission rate
    • Mortality

  • Malnutrition can affect both the underweight (BMI <20 kg/m2) and the overweight (BMI >35 kg/m2)

  • Formal screening of nutrition should take place before any major surgery, e.g. with MUST or NRS-2002
  • Features of malnourishment include:
    • Being underweight
    • >5% weight loss
    • Reduced food intake due to worsening condition
    • Accelerated nutritional deterioration due to severe disease, including major cancer surgery
    • Pre-operative serum albumin <30 g/L
  • If found to be at risk or malnourished, patients should be referred to a dietician for nutritional assessment
  • Head and neck and gastrointestinal cancers are frequently associated with involuntary weight loss and cachexia, making nutrition a particular focus in these groups

Interventions

  • Patients at severe nutritional risk should receive 7 - 14 days of nutritional support, even if this means delaying surgery (including cancer surgery)
  • This may include:
    • Carbohydrate loading pre-operatively (see below)
    • 1.0 - 1.5 g/kg IBW protein to limit nitrogen losses, e.g. high protein oral nutritional supplements such as Fortisip or Fortijuice; most beneficial when combined with exercise training
    • Glutamine, arginine, omega-3 fatty acids and nucleotides (so-called 'immune-modulating nutrition' or immunonutrition)
      • Cancer surgery is usually followed by a period of immunosuppression; immunonutrition aims to improve post-operative immune function
      • May reduce hyperinflammation caused by the surgical stress response
      • Typically commenced 5 - 7 days pre-operatively (durations of 3 - 14 days are described) and continued post-operatively
      • Associated with fewer fistulae in head and neck cancer surgery; may also benefit pancreatic and hepatic cancer surgery
  • Other supplements:
    • Dietary fibre, especially from vegetables, is associated with fewer complications after colorectal cancer surgery
    • Probiotics in colorectal cancer: faster recovery of bowel function, fewer infectious complications and shorter length of stay
    • There is no evidence to support vitamin or mineral supplementation

Carbohydrate loading

  • ERAS/ESPEN guidance aims to avoid prolonged pre-operative fasting:
    • Clear fluids allowed up to 2 hours before surgery
    • Carbohydrate drink: 800 ml the night before and 400 ml on the morning of surgery
  • Benefits:
    • ↓ post-operative insulin resistance by up to 50%
    • ↓ loss of lean body mass and muscle strength
    • ↓ length of stay
  • Now standard practice in most surgical oncology settings, and particularly beneficial in head and neck cancer

Outcomes

  • Evidence suggests:
    • Targeted nutritional therapy can reduce post-operative complications
    • Immune-modulating nutrition can reduce post-operative complications and length of stay
    • Nutritional prehabilitation, either alone or combined with other aspects of prehabilitation, can reduce length of stay

  • Psychological stressors and the fear of surgery produce immunological dysregulation
  • This contributes to post-operative pain, complications inc. wound healing and delayed recovery

  • Psychological support strategies aim to:
    • Reduce psychological distress/anxiety associated with diagnosis & surgery
    • Maximise motivation and empower patients to comply with other parts of the programme

Screening

  • Screening includes the HADS (Hospital anxiety and depression score)
  • Separate scores for depression and anxiety
  • Scores:
    • 0 - 7 = normal
    • 8 - 10 = borderline
    • ≥11 = case of depression/anxiety
  • In cancer, the single-question distress thermometer is frequently used; those scoring >4 complete a problem list (similar to the HADS) and may need additional support

Interventions

  • Providing sensory information i.e. what the perioperative experience will feel like
  • Cognitive behavioural therapy
  • Relaxation techniques
  • Emotion-focused interventions
  • Mindfulness-based interventions
  • Coping strategies
  • Hypnosis
  • Provision of procedural information i.e. details of the patient journey

  • Such interventions may reduce post-operative anxiety and pain, although evidence for reduced morbidity, mortality or length of hospital stay is limited

Educational interventions

  • Information on the upcoming surgery, post-operative management (including complications and pain management) and coping skills
  • Can increase knowledge and satisfaction while reducing pain, anxiety and days in hospital
  • Delivery:
    • A single 15-minute session appears as effective as a 90-minute session
    • In-person, or combined audiovisual and written information, is more effective than a video or leaflet alone
    • Sessions on the day before or day of treatment can increase anxiety and reduce knowledge transfer; earlier delivery is preferable
    • Effects are greater in younger patients
    • Should be tailored: 'information seekers' benefit from more detail, whereas 'information avoiders' may become more anxious
  • Cancer-specific information can influence recovery, e.g. pre-operative stoma education leads to quicker stoma proficiency and shorter length of stay after colon cancer surgery

Cognitive behavioural therapy and relaxation

  • CBT addresses coping with the diagnosis and treatment, and changing unhelpful thoughts and behaviours
    • Increases self-efficacy, which improves adherence to exercise and nutrition interventions
    • Can improve physical function, QoL, fatigue and pain, as well as immune function (e.g. ↑ natural killer cell cytotoxicity)
    • Ranges from a single 45 - 90 minute session to twice weekly sessions for 2 weeks before surgery
  • Relaxation includes meditation, progressive muscle relaxation, Qigong, guided imagery and breathing exercises
    • Can be delivered anytime from the day of biopsy to the morning of surgery
    • Associated with reduced analgesic requirements, pain intensity and anxiety

Complementary medicine

  • Hypnosis may benefit pain, distress, fatigue and nausea
  • Music and aromatherapy are associated with reduced pre-operative anxiety
  • Music and acupuncture may reduce post-operative pain
  • The evidence is currently insufficient to make firm recommendations

  • May only be as effective as rehabilitation
    • Prehabilitation increases functional capacity to a greater extent
    • However no difference in complication rate, hospital length of stay, readmission rates, recovery of walking capacity or patient-reported outcomes

  • Evidence base suffers from:
    • Heterogeneity of studied populations, interventions, and outcome measures
    • Small sample sizes
    • Potential for bias from inclusion of low-risk populations
    • Potential for bias from inability to blind participants
  • This limits robust meta-analysis and the evidence base is relatively weak

  • Evidence for reduced rate of post-operative complications and decreased length of stay is low
  • No demonstrated effect on mortality
  • Some aspects of prehabilitation don't improve outcomes in isolation, but may do so as part of multi-modal intervention programmes (marginal gains theory)
  • May improve functional measures (e.g. VO2 peak, grip strength, global health status) but not clinically relevant outcomes such as morbidity, mortality, length of stay or readmission rates
  • Potential for adverse events from exercise interventions although this has not manifested in the literature
  • May not be cost-saving, although may be cost-effective up to a cost of $9,500/patient

In cancer prehabilitation

  • No studies have yet assessed long-term outcomes such as survival or cancer recurrence
  • No rigorous study has assessed the cost-effectiveness of cancer prehabilitation programmes
  • The optimal modality, intensity and type of prehabilitation is uncertain for most patient groups
  • Uptake is variable (45 - 65%), as is adherence once enrolled (20 - 95%); all measures of effectiveness improve with compliance and adherence
  • 'One size does not fit all':
    • Otherwise healthy patients may need only education or a home-based digital programme
    • Those with poor fitness, malnutrition, psychosocial problems, sarcopenia, frailty or comorbidities may need more specialised care
    • Individualised and community co-designed programmes are likely to improve engagement, adherence and effectiveness